# Read completing the square in Book Isle: a bound still needs an allowed equality case

Language: en
Canonical: [Read completing the square in Book Isle: a bound still needs an allowed equality case](<https://allluckly.cn/en/guides/nasbook-completing-square-minimum-domain-attainment/>)
中文：[中文 HTML](<https://allluckly.cn/guides/nasbook-completing-square-minimum-domain-attainment/>)
English: [English HTML](<https://allluckly.cn/en/guides/nasbook-completing-square-minimum-domain-attainment/>)
Published: 2026-11-17T00:00:00+08:00
Modified: 2026-11-17T16:26:13+08:00
Author: Bison

Rewrite a quadratic as a square plus two and distinguish minimum attainment on real, nonpositive and negative domains.

English translation of the [Chinese original](<https://allluckly.cn/guides/nasbook-completing-square-minimum-domain-attainment/>), translated on 2026-11-17. Original publication dates, attribution, code and version notes are retained.

A nonnegative square alone does not complete a minimum proof: the lower bound must be attained by an allowed input. Use an original card with three domains in Book Isle, retaining algebra, equality conditions and counterexamples. Recalculate externally; the reader is not an automatic optimizer.

## Fix the function and three condition cards

Externally make Q1 with f(x)=x²−6x+11 over all real numbers. Q2 keeps the function but requires x≤0; Q3 uses x\<0. Add markers, export a clear PDF/EPUB and retain editable sources. Import into Book Isle and check all inequality signs and constant eleven, rather than guess a faint equality bar. Record file and card identity so conditions do not silently carry over. For image formulas inspect characters instead of assuming searchable exponents or symbols.

## Add and subtract nine, then expand back

Half of −6 is −3 and its square is 9. Add and subtract 9 to obtain (x−3)²+2, rather than insert 11 into the square. Expanding gives x²−6x+9+2, recovering the original coefficients. Mark added and removed terms together to show the function is unchanged. The erroneous (x−6)²+11 expands to x²−12x+47. Keep that faulty control for checking instead of deleting inconvenient terms until the answer looks right.

```text
f(x)=x^2-6*x+11
=x^2-6*x+9-9+11
=(x-3)^2+2
all real x: f(x)>=2; equality iff x=3
```

## Write the lower bound and equality case separately

A real square is nonnegative, so f≥2. Separately solve (x−3)²=0 to obtain x=3 and verify it belongs to Q1, establishing minimum 2. The first statement alone is only a bound. Highlight inequality and equality separately if the format supports it; otherwise record page locations and keep two-column notes externally. Minimum output 2 differs from attaining input 3. Label point(3, 2), input 3 and output 2 rather than use one unexplained answer number.

## Use symmetric samples as checks rather than proof

For x=1, 2, 3, 4, 5, f=6, 3, 2, 3, 6. Equal distances from 3 give equal values, and f(0)=11 checks the constant. Samples do not exclude a smaller value at an unlisted real input; the square argument proves the whole domain. Any graph is an external aid with labelled axes, not exact values measured from pixels. Keep table and proof separate; the smallest sampled value does not make x=3 valid in every changed domain.

## For Q2 remove the forbidden equality point first

On Q2, x≤0 excludes 3, so minimum 2 cannot be copied. Here x−3≤−3, hence its square is at least 9 and f≥11, attained at x=0. The function is unchanged; allowed inputs changed. f(−1)=18 checks one larger value without proving the entire range. Keep domain x≤0, bound 11 and equality input 0 together so an excerpt never loses its condition. A graph comparison must show only the permitted portion.

Independently use f(x)−f(0)=x(x−6). For x≤0 both factors are nonpositive, so the product is nonnegative and 0 attains that domain’s minimum. For x\<0 it is positive, agreeing with unattained 11 on Q3. The product argument also needs its domain; it is not nonnegative for every real x.

If Q2 retains positive-input samples for comparison, mark them outside-domain references rather than allowed candidates. Evaluating the polynomial at 3 does not make 3 an allowed input on that card.

## Retain a bound without a minimum on Q3

For x\<0 the square exceeds 9 and f\>11, while 0 is excluded. Inputs−0.1 and−0.01 give 11.61 and 11.0601. More generally x=−ε with ε\>0 gives 11+6ε+ε², approaching 11 as ε→0. The infimum 11 is unattained, so Q3 has no minimum. There is no closest negative real number. Restricting to integers would be another domain and cannot be silently substituted to manufacture an answer.

A separate Q4 over negative integers has nearest-to-zero allowed input−1 and minimum 18; other negative integers lie farther from 3. This new number set does not repair Q3’s absence of a real-domain minimum. Label Q4 separately and retain changing the number set as an explicit condition.

## Use a negative-square control to check extremum direction

For real-domain R, g(x)=−(x−3)²+2 has maximum 2, not minimum. The leading minus makes larger squares lower values; g is unbounded below. Similar appearance to Q1 cannot transfer its conclusion. Diagnose constants by expansion, domains by inequalities and attainment by the equality input. A few samples still do not prove a global extremum. Record a specific correction rather than treat finding an answer paragraph as completing the checks.

## Reopen and deliver each card’s conditioned result

Return by bookmark or condition keywords and answer before uncovering results: Q1 minimum 2 at 3, Q2 minimum 11 at 0, Q3 infimum 11 unattained. If search fails, inspect the text layer or use card markers rather than assume deletion. Also verify R’s maximum direction and the faulty expansion. Keep every conclusion linked to conditions, preserving question, derivation, samples and corrections. Leave reopening pending if unperformed and recheck domains after changing editions rather than migrate isolated numerical excerpts.

## Related tutorials and sources

[Quadratic equations and discriminants](<https://allluckly.cn/en/guides/nasbook-quadratic-discriminant-distinct-real-roots/>); [Definitions and counterexamples](<https://allluckly.cn/en/guides/nasbook-definition-necessary-sufficient-boundary/>).

Method references: [OpenStax Precalculus2e section3.2](<https://openstax.org/books/precalculus-2e/pages/3-2-quadratic-functions>). Diagrams, report data, counterexamples and ledgers are original exercises.

Version checked on 17 November 2026: the [Apple public lookup](<https://itunes.apple.com/lookup?id=6766198898&country=cn&entity=software&timestamp=20261117>) lists Book Isle 1.1.4, requiring iOS / iPadOS 15.6 or later; see the [official App Store](<https://apps.apple.com/cn/app/id6766198898>) for published capabilities. Use self-made PDFs, EPUBs or clear text materials; bookmarks, highlights and notes depend on format and visible controls, without automatic solving or literary analysis. External preparation and paper predictions do not constitute device observations. Leave unperformed checks blank.

