Quantitative cards for charge, energy and fields
Read power cards in ManYue: doubling resistance depends on fixed voltage or fixed current
Compare ideal resistors under two supply conditions, separating power, duration and energy while retaining the temperature assumption.
On this page
Two cards saying “resistance increases” can have opposite power changes. Separate fixed-voltage and fixed-current ledgers, read their controlled quantities in ManYue and compare energy bars. No real wiring is required, and colour brightness does not diagnose resistor temperature.
Declare two separate supply models at the top
Use ideal ohmic resistors of 3Ω or 6Ω, each resistance constant during its calculation, excluding temperature-induced changes. P1 fixes terminal voltage at 6V; P2 independently fixes current at 2A. They are not simultaneous conditions of one source experiment. Put units/controls on P3, export a PDF and retain editable work. After import, inspect each heading and bookmark P2. Draw a single resistor symbol rather than secretly change topology.
Recover current from Ohm’s law on the voltage-fixed page
With 6V across each resistor, 3Ω gives I=6/3=2A and 6Ω gives 1A. Doubling resistance halves current; do not retain 2A in the second fixed-6V card. Check V=IR: 2×3=6 and 1×6=6. Voltage is a terminal potential difference, not an unreferenced value at one point. Without duration, proceed to power rather than claim a joule consumption.
Hide resistance labels for an inverse check: at 6V, 6W gives I=P/V=1A and R=6Ω; 12W gives 2A and 3Ω. Recover the original cards rather than assume larger power means larger resistance. The inversion retains nonzero voltage/ohmic conditions. Power alone without voltage/current does not uniquely determine R, and colour supplies no missing input.
Substitute one consistent state into all power forms
P=VI gives 12W and 6W. V²/R gives 36/3 and 36/6, again 12 and 6; I²R gives 4×3 and 1×6. The formulas agree when V, I, R describe the same state. Keep all three inputs on each row instead of importing an incompatible value from another page. The R factor in I²R alone does not imply increasing power with resistance under fixed voltage.
Changing only the 3Ω card from 6V to 12V gives 4A and 48W, four times 12W. Check 12×4=144/3 instead of retaining old 2A. Resistance and duration stay fixed. This tests the square relation under its conditions, not a fourfold guarantee for nonlinear or temperature-changing devices.
Allow voltage to change on the current-fixed page
On P2 fix I=2A: 3Ω requires 6V and 6Ω requires 12V. I²R gives 12W and 24W, doubling with resistance; VI agrees as 2×6 and 2×12. This does not claim a real source supplies unlimited voltage or power. A card retaining 6V,2A,6Ω violates Ohm’s relation. Mark inconsistent conditions before selecting a power answer that hides the conflict.
R values: 3 ohm, 6 ohm; ideal ohmic, constant R
fixed V=6 V: I=(2,1) A; P=(12,6) W
fixed I=2 A: V=(6,12) V; P=(12,24) W
for 5 s: energies fixed-V=(60,30) J; fixed-I=(60,120) J
P=V*I=I^2*R=V^2/R for each consistent state
Separate five-second energy bars from power columns
For 5s at unchanged states, E=Pt gives fixed-voltage energies 60J, 30J and fixed-current energies 60J, 120J. Watts are energy-transfer rates; joules are interval amounts. 12W does not mean 12J over five seconds. A separate 10s control for the 6W resistor gives 60J, matching 12W over 5s despite unequal power. Label duration instead of measuring it from a drawn bar.
For 3Ω at 2A over 2s then 1A over 4s, energy=12×2+3×4=36J and six-second average power=6W. Average current is 4/3A; its square times 3Ω is 16/3W, not the time-averaged power. Squaring is nonlinear. Keep this varying-current control separate from the constant-state five-second cards instead of extending one instantaneous power across a whole interval.
Do not infer temperature or brightness from power alone
P describes electrical-energy conversion rate in ideal resistors. Heat capacity, cooling, area and environment are absent, so 24W supplies no Celsius temperature. Equal-power objects can have different temperatures under different cooling. Lamp brightness also depends on material and efficiency; fixed R is not every filament model. Separate larger power, greater interval energy and higher temperature. With equal duration the first two can be compared here; temperature remains unknown.
Diagnose controlled quantities and incompatible inputs
If both pages say 24W, check whether a fixed-current answer migrated to fixed voltage. A 2 A result with 6V/6Ω requires division checked. “Consumption twelve” lacks watts, joules or time. Enlarge Ω and squares. Correct one controlled quantity or input, then verify with another power form. If source type is absent, record insufficient conditions rather than assume voltage/current control or App parameter recognition.
Reopen and explain the opposite changes
Reopen at the fixed-current bookmark and write 12W→24W, then return to fixed voltage for 12W→6W, explaining why formulas agree. Check four five-second energies and the ten-second equal-energy control. Deliver controlled quantities, V/I/R and power/time ledgers, not merely a red-resistor image. Mark unperformed import/bookmark/reopening pending. These are ideal paper results, not appliance tests, measured heating or validated power-supply plans.
Related tutorials and sources
ManYue current-section ledger; ManYue work conditions.
Method references: OpenStax electrical energy and power. Diagrams, report data, counterexamples and ledgers are original exercises.
Version checked on 19 November 2026: the Apple public lookup lists ManYue 2.0.6, requiring iOS / iPadOS 15.0 or later; see the official App Store for published capabilities. Use self-made PDFs or supported comic images; controls depend on the installed version. External preparation and paper predictions do not constitute device observations. Leave unperformed checks blank.