Concurrency, metric identities, hulls and brackets

VectorPaint Ceva concurrency: internal ratios two, one and one half multiply to one

Locate three cevians in an original right triangle and verify their ratio product, intersection and a nonconcurrent moved-point control.

English translation of the Chinese original, translated on . Original publication dates, attribution, code and version notes are retained.

Draw three lines inside a triangle with exact coordinates and ratios behind the apparent intersection. Restrict division points to side interiors and use positive length ratios, without mixing in signed exterior cases. Their common point need not be the centroid and the lines need not be medians. Calculate division points before connecting each vertex to its opposite side.

Fix a nondegenerate triangle and three side points

Take A=(0,6), B=(0,0), C=(8,0) in mathematical coordinates; they are noncollinear. Put D inside BC, E inside CA and F inside AB, then connect AD, BE and CF without moving names to other sides. On about 1200 × 1100 pixels use u=180+100x, v=900−100y, with equal scales and reversed screen y. Group triangle, division points, cevians, ratios and control separately, then save. Units are abstract lengths, not centimetres; distinguish points from label positions.

Place D at two to one rather than the midpoint

Set BD/DC=2 on the base of length eight, giving BD=16/3, DC=8/3 and D=(16/3,0). Take E=(4,3), the midpoint of CA, so CE/EA=1. Set F=(0,4): AF=2 and FB=4, hence AF/FB=1/2; F’s y-coordinate four is not AF. List numerators and denominators externally before plotting points and leaders. D’s screen x is about 713.333. If precise entry is unavailable, label placement approximate and retain fractions rather than calling a small drag error a theorem failure.

Start each cevian at the opposite vertex

Draw unfilled AD, BE and CF, checking all six endpoints rather than drawing the small triangle DE–EF–FD. Use distinct line styles and one P marker, not three slightly displaced dots. Under these interior conditions Ceva states concurrency if and only if (BD/DC)(CE/EA)(AF/FB)=1; here 2×1×1/2=1. Cyclic reordering is harmless but inverting only one ratio is not. Name segment identities in text instead of relying on three colours.

Solve two lines independently and test the third

AD has y=6−9x/8 and BE has y=3x/4, giving P=(16/5,12/5). CF has y=4−x/2, which also gives 12/5 at x=16/5. Use screen P=(500,660) as a plotting check instead of shifting P to accommodate faulty lines. These are not all medians, so do not label P the centroid: this triangle’s centroid is (8/3,2), a different point. Retain equations in a note box; the visible crossing approximates the calculation. As an independent area check, let X=[ABP], Y=[BCP], Z=[CAP]. Here X=48/5, Y=48/5, Z=24/5, summing to the triangle area 24. Shared heights or ratios along a common vertex line give side ratios X/Z, Y/X, Z/Y, whose product cancels to one. Lightly fill the three checking regions, touching only at boundaries, and keep equal-valued X/Y as distinct regions. This explains the product under the concurrent configuration; do not transfer the same area correspondence to control CF1 missing P. Areas have squared units; their ratios are dimensionless, and 48/5 is not an edge length. If pale regions overlap, check for fills crossing an edge rather than interpreting darker overlap as greater area. Hide these checking fills in the final diagram while retaining the fractional ledger.

A=(0,6); B=(0,0); C=(8,0)
D=(16/3,0); E=(4,3); F=(0,4)
BD/DC=2; CE/EA=1; AF/FB=1/2; product=1
AD: y=6-9*x/8; BE: y=3*x/4; CF: y=4-x/2
P=(16/5,12/5); screen P=(500,660)
control F1=(0,3): product=2
CF1 at x=16/5: y=9/5 != 12/5

Move only F for a nonconcurrent control

Save a control moving only F to F1=(0,3), keeping A, B, C, D and E. Now AF1/F1B=1 and the product is two. AD and BE still meet at P, but CF1 is y=3−3x/8, giving 9/5 at x=16/5 rather than P’s 12/5. Thus the third line misses P. Update the old one-half label to one without changing the triangle or stroke widths. Two intersecting lines do not establish three-line concurrency; test the third.

Separate ratio notes from division marks

Place ratios outside their respective sides, using leaders for long fractions without covering D. Make cevians slightly thinner than triangle sides, P small and clear, and the grid faint. Explanatory arrows must not redefine undirected lines as flows. At small size read vertices and cevians before ratios, with a separate moved-F control frame. For a black crossing mass, reduce stroke weight and move labels rather than deleting a required line or treating closeness as exact equality.

Diagnose side ownership and denominators first

For a product other than one, check that AF measures from A rather than B. For separated crossings, revisit the mathematical P and screen-y subtraction. If D leaves the base, check the fraction was not misread as sixteen divided by zero. If F1 remains at old F, move it by coordinates and reconnect CF1; ordinary paths do not maintain geometric dependencies automatically. Keep the faulty copy and change one item at a time. Restoring the baseline requires F=(0,4) and product one, not just its colour. Exterior points require a separately defined signed-ratio convention.

Reopen and verify concurrency through both examples

Save editable work and fractions, export SVG or PDF and open a PNG separately. At fit-to-window size check endpoints; enlarge for intact denominators in 16/5, 12/5 and control 9/5. Reopen native work, hide P, solve AD with BE again and test CF and CF1 rather than trusting a memorised dot. Deliver interior conditions, products one and two and approximate-placement notes; mark unperformed output checks pending. VectorPaint manually presents lines and text, without automatic Ceva proof, centroid recognition or device-based precision measurement.

VectorPaint triangle medians: check midpoints and the two-thirds centroid position; VectorPaint angle-bisector diagram: six to nine gives four to six, not equal base halves.

Method sources: Gleason: Ceva theorem and concurrency. The source establishes the interior Ceva ratio condition. Triangle, fractional intersection and moved-F control are original calculations, without a dynamic geometry solver.

Version and operation scope: checked on 19 November 2026 against the official VectorPaint listing and Apple public lookup: version 1.0.8, requiring iOS / iPadOS 17.0 or later. Draw manually with published shapes, pen, Bézier nodes, grids/guides, alignment, layers/groups, text and file output through visible installed controls. Prepare definitions and calculations externally; infer no built-in formula, statistics or graph solver. Keep editable native work and inspect SVG, PDF or PNG as needed. SVG/PDF containing imported bitmaps do not automatically become entirely vector. Canvases and samples are original teaching settings, without physical-device execution or real measurement; mark unperformed actions pending.